Whitaker vs Tszyu @ 140

[Xplosive]

Who wins?

[Hex-One]

Who wins?

Whitaker UD.

Pea had a great chin and very good defense. I say Tszyu cant find him and loses a lop-sided dec.

[whiskey]

Tszyu always did well against "cutesy" type fighters. He not only was powerful, but had great timing which was key to his success. I think Whitaker decisions him, but it's not a route.

[Erratic]

Poor Tszyu.

Always losing in mythical matchups here.

I agree that he makes it competitive though.

[Tam Tam]

Tszyu KO7

[ghoster]

Tszyu would look but never find Sweet Pea.

[jaws1216]

timing beats speed.

Whitaker is clearly the greater fighter, and the better fighter, but this is a tough match-up.

Tszyu was a very good boxer, and the way he stalked people makes me think he could negate some of Pea's best traits, namely his controlling pace with movement.

with his range finding left held high, its tough for opponents to control the fight against him.

I think he'd win a close decision by being more active, and landing the much better looking shots.

[joony]

tszyu looked like shit vs. a one-legged mitchell. just because he zapped Zab in two and beat up an old Mitchell in the rematch doesn't mean that he beats Whitaker, who's light years better than those two.

whitaker also whupped a younger version of roger mayweather. tszyu fought an old ass roger and failed to impress in winning a 12 round clinch fest.

[Tam Tam]

whitaker also whupped a younger version of roger mayweather. tszyu fought an old ass roger and failed to impress in winning a 12 round clinch fest.
:jester: Whitaker wouldn't even remember that fight like you and I do. He was knocked out at one point, whereas Tszyu beat the piss out of old man Mayweather.

[Maverick]

:jester: Whitaker wouldn't even remember that fight like you and I do. He was knocked out at one point, whereas Tszyu beat the piss out of old man Mayweather.


Point is, he won the fight clearly.

[Tam Tam]

Point is, he won the fight clearly.
And Tszyu didn't? He was the one who brought up the Mayweather fight; not me. I think it was foolish to bring Roger into the debate if you're backing Whitaker...because Roger landed one punch the whole fight and almost killed Pernell with it.

Tszyu didn't miss many opportunities to bust a straight right onto the jaw of some defense first lefty.

[cdogg187]

Whitaker by decision.

Tszyu would make him work for it, though.

Strong, persistent, and he had the only punch that ever consistently troubled Pete: Staright Right

Whitaker just a little too quick, a little too sharp.

[Neil]

roger said he thinks Whitaker would have beat the dog shit out of Tszyu. i think whitaker would have won a decision.

[Double L]

roger said he thinks Whitaker would have beat the dog shit out of Tszyu. i think whitaker would have won a decision.

yeah. Roger's never wrong.

[Maverick]

And Tszyu didn't? He was the one who brought up the Mayweather fight; not me. I think it was foolish to bring Roger into the debate if you're backing Whitaker...because Roger landed one punch the whole fight and almost killed Pernell with it.

Tszyu didn't miss many opportunities to bust a straight right onto the jaw of some defense first lefty.


Your point would be vaild had Whitaker lost the fight. Julio Cesar Chavez said that Roger Mayweather hit him the hardest he had ever been hit with. Chavaz said the punch hurt him so badly he need at least 2 minutes to get his head completely straight. Roger was no featherfisted guy.

Whitaker was rocked, but your leaving out how he not only recovered moments later, but contiuned to outclass Mayweather after that. The punch Roger landed was due to Pernell's clowning if I remember correctly.

[Tam Tam]

Your point would be vaild had Whitaker lost the fight. Julio Cesar Chavez said that Roger Mayweather hit him the hardest he had ever been hit with. Chavaz said the punch hurt him so badly he need at least 2 minutes to get his head completely straight. Roger was no featherfisted guy.

Whitaker was rocked, but your leaving out how he not only recovered moments later, but contiuned to outclass Mayweather after that. The punch Roger landed was due to Pernell's clowning if I remember correctly.
Recovered moments later? Dude, he held on for dear life and rode the round out. The guy was knocked shitless. You don't remember correctly.

And my point would be valid? :jester: Tszyu wins the easiest of decisions and has no trouble at all in a boring fight...Whitaker has no trouble at all...cept for the part where he was on the canvas and almost out cold. Again, *I* wasn't the one who raised the Mayweather fight to prop someone up. If I wanted something positive for Whitaker, I'd mention about 25 other fights of his, against good comp...where he didn't have to survive a near death experience.

[Maverick]

Recovered moments later? Dude, he held on for dear life and rode the round out. The guy was knocked shitless. You don't remember correctly.

And my point would be valid? :jester: Tszyu wins the easiest of decisions and has no trouble at all in a boring fight...Whitaker has no trouble at all...cept for the part where he was on the canvas and almost out cold. Again, *I* wasn't the one who raised the Mayweather fight to prop someone up. If I wanted something positive for Whitaker, I'd mention about 25 other fights of his, against good comp...where he didn't have to survive a near death experience.

Fine whatever even if he was hurt for alot longer, he still bounced back and outclassed Mayweather. Bottomline is Whitaker won the fight by a large amount. I have no problem with you picking Tszyu, but the fact that this knockdown is even an issue is useless. Mayweather landed a punch that hurt Whitaker, even though Mayweather STILL LOST the fight very convincingly, how does this knockdown even matter? How is it that Whitaker still out fougth Mayweather's ass after the round he got hurt in not even mentioned? So really bringing up the knockdown itself is a bit ridicilous, seeing how it didn't change the outcome of the fight one bit.

[jaws1216]

Fine whatever even if he was hurt for alot longer, he still bounced back and outclassed Mayweather. Bottomline is Whitaker won the fight by a large amount. I have no problem with you picking Tszyu, but the fact that this knockdown is even an issue is useless. Mayweather landed a punch that hurt Whitaker, even though Mayweather STILL LOST the fight very convincingly, how does this knockdown even matter? How is it that Whitaker still out fougth Mayweather's ass after the round he got hurt in not even mentioned? So really bringing up the knockdown itself is a bit ridicilous, seeing how it didn't change the outcome of the fight one bit.

Unless you are comparing how Whitaker fared against him versus how Tszyu fared. Especially when an implication is made that Whitaker did "better" against him. Lets see, guy who wins handily and controlles nearly the entire fight, or guy who wins handily and was put on queer street for a round.

[Maverick]

Unless you are comparing how Whitaker fared against him versus how Tszyu fared. Especially when an implication is made that Whitaker did "better" against him. Lets see, guy who wins handily and controlles nearly the entire fight, or guy who wins handily and was put on queer street for a round.


First, I wasn't comparing. I'm just saying regardless of the fact that Whitaker was hurt, he still won convincingly.

Second, you do know that Whitaker fought and beat a better version of Mayweather who was about a decade younger then the one Tszyu beat right?

[Maverick]

Unless you are comparing how Whitaker fared against him versus how Tszyu fared. Especially when an implication is made that Whitaker did "better" against him. Lets see, guy who wins handily and controlles nearly the entire fight, or guy who wins handily and was put on queer street for a round.


First, I wasn't comparing, I'm just saying regardless of the fact that Whitaker was hurt, he still won convincingly.

Also, you do know that Whitaker fought and beat a better version of Mayweather who was about a decade younger then the one Tszyu beat right?

[Alabama_Man]

lol @ the people in here comparing mid-30s Roger Mayweather to mid-20s Roger Mayweather. :jester:

[joony]

:jester: Whitaker wouldn't even remember that fight like you and I do. He was knocked out at one point, whereas Tszyu beat the piss out of old man Mayweather.

you know tszyu's one of my favorite fighters. i think this is a competitive fight, but i wouldnt hesistate to pick whitaker.

[Tam Tam]

you know tszyu's one of my favorite fighters. i think this is a competitive fight, but i wouldnt hesistate to pick whitaker.
And you know I have no problem with anyone picking Whitaker. Its the smart pick. I only took issue with your use of the Mayweather fight as evidence, bro.