I'd take prime Mitchell to beat Haney. It's not being overly nostalgic to say that 25 years ago, Haney would be a non-factor at 140. It's simply fact. Mitchell would beat him, and Tszyu and Judah would put him in a hospital.
Haney. Sharmba was pretty average. Would be a rather close and ugly fight, but haney simply would land the cleaner shots
Mitchell was better than "average." He wasn't elite, but neither is Haney. Mitchell had faster hands, and more pop. If anything, he would land the cleaner shots.