It wont be a popular pick, but I like Moore here. He was strong and he had power and Shane had neither the power nor the skills to really overcome that Of course, to those of you who mistakenly believe Shane Mosley was great, this is sacriledge
Moore wins if its a washed up Shane at 154. If a prime/ or semi-prime Shane moved to 154.... I'd defintely go with Shane. And no, Davey Moore was hardly a push over. He was a damn good fighter. But prime Shane certainly had the tools to beat him.
Shane is probably a better fighter, but he is really not very good at 154. Moore was a natural 154 pounder, he'd beat Shane at that weight.
Shane did next to nothing at 154 except win a questionable decision against DLH... He did not punch particularly hard... we all know he wasn't much of a boxer