If Judah could take Mathysse's best punches for twelve rounds, Gatti could too. Gatti's edge in handspeed earns him a close decision victory
Even the Matthyse that fought Judah would kill Gatti. Even a faded Judah is harder to hit than the best Gatti.
The guy who mentioned it in this topic was being sarcastic I don't think too many people would think Gatti could beat this guy, I certainly don't