P4P rankings

http://www.sherdog.com/news/rankings/Sherdogcoms-Pound-for-Pound-Top-10-32078

So Sherdog has GSP at the top. I guess its hard to argue with. One thing that suprises me a bit, is keeping Shogun in the top 10. After being completey dominated and tko'd I would think it would take you out of the top 10.

 

Guys stay tuned. I will be putting out the Fightbeat Top 10 this evening to generate a little discussion.

 

If it's the "Fightbeat" top ten then you better start a poll. Or it will be the Trplsec top ten and not a reflection of fightbeat itself.

 

He's actually more proven than Berto and has the balls to fight legit fighters, so he's not the Berto of MMA at all.

However, he IS an overachiever and I really don't think he should be on a P4P list.

GSP is #1 beyond argument IMO, boring or not. The most dominant wins over legit competition for a few years now.

And having Rashad, Rua and Fitch above BJ is fucking ridiculous. BJ was robbed against Fitch, and was clearly the smaller man. I also thought Edgar 1 was a total robbery.

 

It's Still EARLY to Rank Bones Jones Toooo HIGHLY, but it'll Look Pretty SILLY (Years from Now) that Frankie Edgar was EVER Ranked HIGHER, Lb for Lb...Especially Anytime AFTER Jones' Win Over Shogun...



REED:hammert:

 

Just wait.. It will be open for participation and hopefully a cool method.

 

I think the removing of BJ out of the top 10 is a farce. Like MWS said, his losses to Edgar were very close, the first being somewhat contraversial. Then he draws with a guy who was on most peoples P4P 10 list in Fitch. Evans has been starched and Shogun was straight beat up. The list is extremely contradictive.

Trplsec, can we PM our top ten to you or how do you want to do this?

 

Nothing shameless about pimpin, it ain't easy, dawg:kidcool:

 

Gotta disagree there man. Edgar beating Sherk, Penn x2, Miller, and Griffin is pretty impressive. Jones has won at the highest level more impressively, but Edgar has done it more. The only difference here is the size difference that Bones usually has.
Bones is just hitting his stride though. I could easily see him at the top of the list in a couple of
fights.

 

How can they have Fitch at #5 and BJ not on the list?

 

Totally agree, man I forgot about Shogun. He just got demolished and he is above BJ? ::

And Fitch at #5, I mean really, wtf.

If anyone won that fight it was BJ, and he is smaller than Fitch too.

Absurd list.