Martinez at both weights, via having some boxing ability and a serviceable jab, and not being stupid enough to stand in front of Tito and eat his dead weight retard hooks.
Agree, yet less so than Trinidad who is a top 3 overrated fighter ever in history. The guy couldn't fight a lick.
Martinez UD I might too, but styles make fights. Vargas fighting a smarter fight might have beaten Tito, aside from that (Tito not cheating by throwing low blows would likely have caused him to lose as well).