Scream vs I Know what you did last Summer vs Urban Legend

Three way matchup!!

Who wins?

 

I Know What You Did Last Summer is the weakest link. That movie is complete, and utter shit.

Scream is technically better than Urban Legend, but I enjoyed Urban Legend more.

 

Scream was actually a pretty good take on the slasher genre. I'd say it wins.

 

Scream is my favourite but I'm surprised by your hate for IKWYDLS...I thought it was clearly better than Urban Legend and just a hair behind scream.

 

By the way...Jennifer Love Hewitt would have gotten it!!!!! All day and all night for a week straight....

 

Something we can all agree on.

 

Scream is another movie that borrowed from Black Christmas. The tone of the killers voice while on the phone is STRAIGHT out of Black Christmas.

 

"Scream" easily.

X is right. The "Last Summer" franchise is fucking awful. All of them. It's "Scream" without the satire, which is basically pointless.

I don't even really remember the other one.

 

Urban Legend was the least comercially successful of the three, but it's a decent slasher flick.

The opening scene in Urban Legend is probably better than any one scene in Scream.

 

I'd agree with that. Tremendous opening scene.

 

Scream wins this. What about Jeepers Creepers? Any fans?