Buddy McGirt vs Marlon Starling

Who wins?

 

McGirt wouldn't be able to out-box Starling like he did Brown

 

I'm a big McGirt fan so I'm probably biased but I think that he was smarter than Starling and would decision him. I also think that there is a very good chance that it would not be a barnburner of a fight.

 

Who do we think had the better performance vs Brown?

 

Starling imo, but its rarely mentioned.

 

I think that Brown was a better fighter when he fought McGirt than he was for the Starling fight.

 

Really? I thought the SD was bogus, but I remember a good two way boxing match. McGirt took him to school from beginning to end.

 

Very ironic, but I actually JUST finished rewatching Starling-Brown 10 minutes ago. It had been years since I saw it.

I was wrong. McGirt's performance was in fact better.