Better fighter: Barry McGuigan or Ray Mancini

Both are in the HOF, and neither really deserve to be in the HOF. Both were pressure fighters. Barry was without question more talented, but Mancini I would say was tougher.

Who was better?

 

Have these two ever won a fantasy H2H?

I think Mancini was better, but I am a Mancini fan.

 

LOL. They tend to be matched in fantasy H2H's with better fighters.

I like Mancini more, but my objective answer is McGugian.

I think mid-80s McGugian peaked higher than early-80s Mancini did.

 

I think Barry was better but I prefer watching Mancini.

 

McGuigan beat Pedroza so he probably was better but Mancini had the better career.