How does Commey do against Haney, Garcia, Tank and Kambosos?

How well does he do?

 

Loses to all them except possibly of the social media Queen.

Cruz would beat the Hell outta Commey too.

 

He gives as good as he gets against the guys mentioned but I wouldn't favour him against any of them.

 

Commey's a GATE KEEPER w/Power...Tough, Proud Fighter, But he Loses to ELITE Lightweights...

His BEST Chances are Against Dev and KingRy...If Dev Hung in the Pocket as he Did vs. JoJo, it's a 70/30 Fight, But if He Fought SMART He Could 12-0 Commey...

Puncher's Chance vs KingRy as Well, but the More LIKELY Scenario is Commey Getting BOMBED Out in 4 or 5 Rounds...




REED

 

REED Wasn't as Impressed w/Cruz as the Rest of the Boxing World, it Seems...

Commey-Cruz is a GOOD Fight in REED's Opinion...





REED

 

Its Commey who's never impressed me. The guy lost to Easter Bunny.

 

Cruz Would Probably LOSE to E-Bunny Also...

Like Commey, Cruz Makes for FUN Fights, But He Damn Sure Ain't SPECIAL Either...



REED

 

cruz would not lose to easter imo

 

Cruz ISN'T a Concussive, 1 Hitter Quitter and E-Bunny is MORE Than Half a Footer Taller, w/a Fucking 13 Inch Reach Advantage...

Cruz WOULD Lose to Easter Also, in REED's Opinion...Again, REED Ain't Even Sure Cruz Beats Commey...





REED

 

Cruz impressed me vs Davis, but not in a way for me to make him a large favourite over anybody mentioned in this thread. There's a lot Davis could've done to separate himself, and it's his lack of discipline which causes him not to. Commey's massive advantages in height and reach would be hard to overcome, and he's both not shy of exchanging and has a big workrate and big punch. He can work the body well, too. Commey would win a war IMO - neither fighter is anything special IMO.

And a Cruz-Easter fight would be a similar sort of close, nap and tuck fight. Easter is more proven than any of these new age lightweights.

 

Exactly...

No Shade @ Cruz; He Won the EVENT, if Not the Fight...Increased his Profile Within Boxing Circles...But as You've Stated, the Tank Fight was About What Tank DIDN'T Do, More Than Anything Cruz Did HIMSELF...

If Tank Doesn't HURT His Power Hand, Cruz Gets Stopped Eventually...

Like You, REED Sees NATHAN to Make Him Definitively Pick Cruz Over Commey or Bunny Easter...






REED

 

I think what harmed Tank more than his injury, was his lack of discipline and poor game plan. He clearly went in there expecting to bomb Cruz out by walking him down and letting him set himself up. He's a known slacker and I'm fairly certain he knew he could roll out of bed after two years of not training and still knock Rolly out. I doubt he was in the best condition he could be in for Cruz, and would've been far better served standing in the pocket off the ropes with Cruz. He's a collosal puncher, with fast hands and superior technique. He's also a top notch counter-puncher. I think if he devoted himself to holding his feet, going downstairs and outworking Cruz, he'd have walked away with it and stopped Cruz IMO. The injury was just the icing on the cake.

I also notice how many people are showing severe double standards regarding Tank's injury, and Loma's.

 

What Do You Mean By "Two Years of Not Training"???...

REED Actually Thinks Tank has Been MORE (Not Significantly More) Dedicated to Conditioning Lately...Haven't Seen Him BLOW UP Between Fights as He Used to Do, in the Last Year or So...agREED Cruz was a TOUGHER Task than Rolly Would've Been, However...

Regarding the Injury, Loma PLAYED HIMSELF Bruh...For 1, He was Tooooooooo ARROGANT to Put a Rematch Clause in the 'Fimo Contract AND He Didn't Speak of His Injury @ All Until AFTER the Fact...

Conversely, it was OBVIOUS Tank was Compromised in Some Way, In Real Time...Loma's Last 2 Fights Have CLEARLY Demonstrated He Wasn't "Right" That Night, But the Double Standard is His Own Doing in REED's Opinion...






REED

 

Just in theory. Tank knows be could fuck about and not train a day and still annihilate Romero.

While I do think he's been more dedicated as of late, I don't trust Tank's work ethic after the farce of losing his title multiple times to weight and being in such poor condition for Gamboa - which is a fight which for some reason gets forgotten, like really? This guy is supposed to be one of the best finisher in the world? - but I do think there could've been some been some problems in camp of why he didn't bother working with Cruz.

And I don't think there's any cause for saying Lomachenko never mentioned he had the shoulder injury beforehand. He's had that injury lingering around for years. He injured it badly years ago vs Linares and cartilage damage doesn't repair well naturally - especially not while training at the highest level. Loma supposedly reinjured himself in the second, after having trouble with the injury before the fight.

He didn't even use his lead hand for like five rounds after damaging it, as soon as the injury was announced, it made tons of sense why he didn't do anything for six rounds. I don't think Tank keeping his hands down while Lomachenko keeping them up should make a major difference in how you view them.

Given how much Loma conceded to make the Lopez fight, literally having to give up a portion of his own purse, then I highly doubt he'd have been able to make the fight had he banged a rematch clause in there. Furthermore, I don't think it should make any difference whether he had a rematch clause or not when evaluating the severity of his injury vs Tank's.

 

Bruh, Teofimo ASKED for a Rematch Clause and was Told "Loma Doesn't Do Rematch Clauses"...

You're Attempting to Make EVERY Possible Excuse for Loma, but the Lack of a Rematch Clause was HISfuckingFAULT Exclusively & Would've Rendered His Injury MEANINGLESS Because He Would've Had a Built In, Immediate Re-Do to Potentially Rectify the Situation...

Despite the Injury History You Speak Of, Loma Felt He DIDN'T Need a Rematch Clause vs. 'Fimo, THEN Bitched About the Injury AFTER the Fact...

Like REED Said, Loma PLAYED HIMSELF...

Knowing Full Well the Likes of Muhammad Ali, Sugar Ray Leonard, Mike Tyson, Roy Jones, Oscar Dela Hoya, Floyd Maywether, Canelo Alvarez, etc., ALWAYS Had Rematch Clauses in their Contracts, How Can You ABSOLVE Loma for NOT Having One for the 'Fimo Fight???...WHOthefuck is He, By Comparison???

He PLAYED Himself, Period...

He CREATED the "Double Standard" You Speak Of...No 2 Ways About It....Literally, You're Going Into a Fight Injured, You WILLINGLY Shunned a Rematch Clause, Yet the Boxing World is Supposed to Feel SORRY For You When You Reveal the INJURY After the Fact???...

Loma Has EVERY Right to Think HIGHLY Of Himself, but the Lopez/Rematch Clause Scenario was a Clear Case of ARROGANCE Biting Him in the Ass...@ a Certain Level, EVERYBODY Has Rematch Clauses for EVERY Opponent They Face...




REED

 

JRE MMA Show #116 with George Kambosos

 

Losses to all of them except Tank Davis.

you said Tank would knock him out in 3 or 5 rds so I can see why. he made you look silly,

 

You think he beats Davis??

 

If Getting a Prediction Wrong is an Example of Being Made to “Look Silly”, REED Guarantees You’ve Looked Like a Complete DUMBFUCK By Comparison…




REED

 

I'll be honest if Tank had been in there with Commey last week I think he would stand a good chance at beating him. But he did take a beating last saturday and the way he did the stanky leg makes me think he's seen better days, But yeah right now I give him a 50-50 chance.

 

Getting a prediction wrong doesn't make you look silly. But not giving a fighter his props when he clearly earned it is not just silly but stubborn too. And how did I look silly when I was one of the few that said from the very beginning that Cruz was a much tougher opponent for Tank than Romero?

 

Tank would beat the fuck outta Commey.

 

REED Genuinely WASN’T Impressed by Cruz, Get the Fuck Over It…

George Actually agREED the Fight was More About What Tank DIDN’T Do Than Anything Cruz Actually DID Himself, Yet You’re Only RIDING REED’s Nuts, After the Fact…

You Make it Seem Like Tank LOST or Something…NOPE! REED Picked the Right Guy Who was WELL On His Way to Stopping Cruz (Later Than REED Projected, Admittedly)…

And Here Your Bitchass Is, Sniffing REED’s Nuts Because Cruz Lasted the Distance??? You Wanna Give Him a Pat on the Head and a Participation Medal, Cool…

Just Don’t Be a Fucking Asshole Because Some were LESS Than Impressed…





REED

 

I'm not being an asshole. I'm simply stating the facts. Everyone saw a close fight that could have gone either way. Even Sergio Mora from showtime had Cruz ahead. It's not like a George Kombosos dominating performance vs Teo Fimo...winning every round. Tank got exposed vs a late replacement who he had every advantage over in reach, height, power, speed, experience and pedigree yet in a what was supposed to be a showcase fight he couldnt close the show. Everyone knows you can only win by knockout against the Money team. I'ts not that I dont think Tank is not a good fighter I just dont think he's as good as you think he is, but fair enough you weren't impressed we can agree to disagree.

 

You Don’t Even KNOW How Good REED Thinks Tank Is; Instead, You’ve Made an IGNORANT Ass Assumption Based On What You THINK REED’s Opinion Will Be, Without Bothering to ASK!!!…

REED Also PREDICTED Tank Would Have Trouble w/Barrios…& Up UNTIL He KO’ed LSC, REED Is On Record Stating He’d Never Been LESS Impressed w/Tank…

Saying REED was Made to “Look Silly” Because Tank FAILED to KO Cruz is an Asshole, Attention Seeking Move…

Get a Life AND a New Sack to Swing From Bruh; REED Ain’t Interested…






REED

 

Just to throw my own two cents on thread subject in, I'd wager Commey loses to all of them but I wouldn't be surprised if he stopped Haney or Garica. I'd give him the best chance against Haney between them two, who I think is likely the worst of the bunch. Tank, Kambosos and obviously Lopez are too much for him.

He should be favoured over Cruz and Diaz IMO.

 

Richard Commey isn't particularly good. Cruz is no great either, but he's younger, stronger, and has a much better chin. That would be the difference.

 

What Evidence is There of Cruz’s Strength???

REED Thinks You’re Confusing AGGRESSION w/Strength…Sure, Cruz is More Consistently AGGRESSIVE Than Commey, But STRONGER???

Based On???






REED

 

I think Commey is decent. Far from great, obviously, but a solid fighter. I don't think there's a big difference between Cruz and Commey, and definitely not one in Cruz's favour. Cruz's performance vs Davis impressed me and made me realise I was wrong about him but even still, I think a fight between Commey and Cruz would be a close war no matter who won.

 

That would be a nice undercard fight.