Your top 5 all-time P4P list

What? YES HE IS.....

 

TROLL...

 

Chavez is hardly the only one in that list unmentionable in a top-5.

 

That whole list is just wrong....

 

Of course, the whole list is ridiculous, I just mentioned Chavez because he was listed as 1 ;)

 

This forum needs a wink emoticon.

 

best fighters Ive seen fight in no particular order:

Ray Leonard
Roy Jones Jr
Marcellus Johnson
Roberto Duran
Pernell Whitaker

 

Out of curiosity, who would you have classed as the greater Lightweight --- Whitaker, or Duran?

 

duran

 

Of course he bitchfucked everybody's darling, Duran, and got jobbed against Leonard in the rematch. I think you can put Hearns wherever you want on a p4p list, but he's just not as popular to lick as others.

 

Putting Chavez below 50 is far more ridiculous than putting him at 1.

 

I have to disagree there. While Chavez certainly makes my top-50, it would be a hell of a lot more reasonable, in my view, to find fifty men ahead of him through history than it would be to put him at number-one --- I know that was a trolling list, but anyone seriously stocking Chavez as numero uno is unforgivable.

 

chavez at 135-unbeatable. Thats why whitaker ducked him at 140

 

Duran would make Chavez his bitch at 135.....

 

troll

 

no thats feasible....Duran would punk Chavez...

 

You don't think JC Chavez is top 50???:laugh11:

 

While I would definitely pick Duran over Chavez....it wouldn't be easy at all. Great fight imho. Both guys would beat Pryor i think

 

Agreed on all counts. Duran would definitely be a favourite, but Chavez was a veritable beast at 135, & a push-over for no man. I give him a fairly narrow advantage head-to-head against Pryor, too.

 

Oh, I almost forgot.


1. Robinson
2. Duran
3. Hammerin' Henry
4. Ali
5. Jofre

 

Who do you think woulda won between Duran and Pea?

 

1) Ezzard Charles
2) Ray Robinson
3) Henry Armstrong
4) Roberto Duran
5) Muhammad Ali
6) Willie Pep
7) Ray Leonard
8) Joe Louis
9) Eder Jofre
T) Pernel Whitaker

 

You response to a "troll list" with this nonsense?

 

^ What Sly said. Chavez is undisputably top 30.

 

whitaker
roy jones
duran
leonard
floyd

 

If people haven't even seen or investigated anybody prior to 1978 they should just probably refrain from posting. Nah'm sayin'????

 

pacquiao is definitely up there. top 10 for sure if not top 5. those lists don't mean much to me anyhow.

 

I'll reserve judgement on Pac & Floyd until they fight/retire. If Floyd schools the shit out of Pac allot of things are gonna change in our perceptions.

 

Word. It's ridiculous.

Anyway;

1. Pacquiao
2. Khan
3. RJJ
4. Mayweather
5. De La Hoya

 

Charles should really be in everyone's top-5 --- top-10, at a minimum.

Given their simply astonishing records, I'm assuming you precluded Greb & Langford from your calculations based on the dearth of footage?