If EMM lets his hands go, i think he wins a very clear decision, just from harder, more effective punching... but I can just as likely see him posing, trying to land one perfect shot while Hill jabs and moves and steals rounds... all things being equal, both guys bringing it, I'm going to take the banger, because Hill was a very GOOD boxer, but not a great boxer, he could be hit and he wasn't a big hitter... EMM on (harold lederman voice) "clean, effective punchin' ... JIM!"
Assuming Eddie's at his best.... he kicks Hill's ass and wins a clear UD. Probably scoring a knockdown of Virgil along the way.