Two EXTREMELY talented/skilled techncians who's downfalls were that they were lazy fucks. But assuming both came in at their bests, who wins? I'm going with EMM.
The fight is at 175, you fucking idiot, what the hell does 168 or heavy have to do with anything? He had zero fights at 168 (which didn't EXIST, for fuck's sake) and maybe 2 at heavy (because he didn't eat his own weight in hot dogs)
Why do you have to get all teenage girl with me. My point is, the fact Emm's success was at 175 while Toney's was elsewhere is not a solid case for picking Emm.
The style matchup in general favors Eddie. Toney wouldnt outbox Eddie from the outside, and EMM hit MORE than hard enough to keep JT honest.
No it's not. It'd be different if Toney had never fought above 168. But he did. And with success. In and of itself, it's a unconvincing case.
of course it is! One guy was damn near great at the weight the other was a footnote at it Chavez/Quartey at 147... who ya got? You going to pick Chavez because he was great from 130-140 or are you going to look at the weight and say "no that is ridiculous"
at 190 against a guy tailor made for him in Jirov and at heavyweight in the worst era ever against a washed-up old man, a skilless bum and a professional holder For what it's worth, EMM would school Jirov at 190... I have no doubt about it
