Ahh fuck it! I'll answer it. Gimme Benitez. By close decision over Curry, and wide decision over Tito. Curry vs Tito is a fight where I'd pick Curry, but not with alot of confidence. He could be winning handily, but I have zero faith in him handling Tito's power. Like I said, all 3 beat Ike.
I would take Benitez at his best over all 3. Trinidad would come back from behind to stop Curry late IMO, he'd probably also stop Ike late, and he'd lose to El Radar via UD. With Benitez there is always a question of motivation and his chin can be cracked but he's just so skillful that Tito wouldn't find him.