Napoles pretty clearly... McGirt might get in a nice counter hook here and there, but he'd be forced to be overly defensive... can't match offensive skills with Napoles... I figure Jose either decisions him wide or stops him late
I was at the Mirage when Buddy whipped Simon Brown and he put together one of the most complete displays of boxing I've ever seen. But he would not have been able to do that to Napoles, no welterweight could. Buddy would be in there with him and have a couple of moments here and there, but Mantequilla gets him out of there in about 9 or 10.