Two extremely talented, yet extremely LAZY motherfuckers. Both very inconsistent, yet when they were on, both were superb. Assuming both bring their A games, who woulda won?
It'd Definitely Be a CHESS Match & Go the Distance, 12 or 15 Rounds...The BUILD-UP would Be Entertaining as Well... Ultimately, REED Gives the Edge to Mustafa Muhammad, Slightly...Naturally Bigger Man & the Fight's @ 175...He WOULDN'T Dominate or Embarrass Toney, but he'd SLIGHTLY Outwork Him...Also, Mustafa had SUPERIOR POWER, so Toney Might Be a Tad More HESITANT to Counter, After Tasting a Shot or 2... If they Fought 10 Times, it'd Probably Be 6-4, Mustafa... REED:hammert:
EMM by decision via the harder punches... He's better long-range and in a battle of two old-school counterpunchers with all other things being equal, I like the taller guy with the better long-range game to win it... That's Eddie and Toney would have to respect his power Like Hut said, lots of outstanding skill on display here... of course, like X said, there's also the chance for lots of uninspired loafing too::
