Fights where a fighter was unable to avenge a controversial loss/draw in the rematch

What are some fights that you can think of where a fighter was wrongfully robbed of a win via decision loss or draw, but failed to avenge that outcome in the rematch?

First to come mind would be Joe Louis vs Jersey Joe Walcott.

 

Bute vs andrande

Jcc vs taylor


Ward vs kovy (even though the second fight was also a disgustingly corrupted affair)

 

Floyd-JLC

Not a decision, but Coggi-Gonzalez is the biggest robbery in boxing, Gonzalez KO'd Coggi a million times but wound up losing

Then in the re-match, Coggi beats Gonzalez clean anyway

 

For sure i fucking loathe Coggi cause of that fight. Completely outrageous



But it was pretty obvious he was gonna win the re. Gonzalez ko in the first was the definition of fluke

 

Fenech against Nelson and Harada against Famechon were the first two I thought of.

 

Rogan-Sexton

 

Hasim Rahman got screwed in the first David Tua match with the late hit and bad stoppage. Then a fat Rahman probably should have gotten the decision in the rematch and they ruled it a draw.

GGG should have gotten the decision in the first Canelo fight. Canelo was lucky to get a draw in that one. The rematch could have gone either way (I had it 114-114), but we all knew Canelo would get the nod in a close decision.

It’s been awhile since I saw the James Toney-Montell Griffin fights, but I remember thinking Toney should have won both, and Griffin got the decisions both times

 

Bones Adam vs Atala
Espada vs Morales

 

Pascual Perez-Kingpetch
Mark Johnson-Rafael Marquez
Rocchigiani-Dariusz M.

 

Somehow, I overlooked Rosario-Ramirez II.

Rosario-Randall II probably also qualifies.

EDIT: Oops, wrong thread!

 

I've always scored both of those clearly for Rosario.

 

Gonzalez-Sor Rungvisai II
Tiger-Griffith II
Griffith-Archer II
Watanabe-Poonterat II

 

Watson v Eubank I was an awful robbery. Eubank near killed him in the rematch despite being outclassed for almost all of it.

MTF

 

I actually meant to post those in the "rematches better than the original thread." My bad.

 

But getting back to the thread topic:

Mario Martinez vs. Azumah Nelson

 

Ayala/Tapia
Ayala/Adams

 

Tapia actually did avenge the 1st fight - only to be robbed much harder.