Whats the final verdict on EJ as a fighter? Was he: Good Very good Great ATG I was a fan of him since 2015, but in the end, I can't in good conscious consider him a great. I think he firmly falls into the category of very good. Yes, I accept that he'll make the HOF, but I think in quality he falls shy of the great welters.
I dont see how you can rate him differently. Very good but not great fighter. Id put him a bit below Ike Quartey