Create the perfect p4p fighter using CURRENTLY ACTIVE fighters.

Let's have some fun, We havent done this for a long time, I got the idea off at max forums.

Using these attributes, who's traits would you use to fill in the following:

1. Stamina
2. Boxing ability
3. Defense
4. Chin
5. Footwork
6. Speed
7. Power
8. Killer instinct
9. Ring smarts
10. Heart
:bears:

 

Stamina- Manny Pacquiao
Boxing ability- Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Defense- Floyd Mayweather Jr.
Chin- Oliver McCall
Speed- Zab Judah
Power- Rafael Marquez
Ring smarts- Bernard Hopkins
Heart- Lamon Brewster

 

1. Stamina: Juan Diaz
2. Boxing ability: Mayweather
3. Defense: Mayweather
4. Chin: Toney
5. Footwork: Hopkins
6. Speed: Judah
7. Power: Wlad Klitschko
8. Killer instinct: Pacquiao
9. Ring smarts: Mayweather
10. Heart: Pacquiao

 

Ok here are my picksopcorn:


1. Stamina-Ricky Hatton
2. Boxing ability-Bernard Hopkins
3. Defense-Floyd Mayweather
4. Chin-Evander Holyfield
5. Footwork-Hopkins
6. Speed-Zab Judah
7. Power-Cotto
8. Killer instinct-Pacman
9. Ring smarts-Bernard Hopkins
10. Heart-Miguel Cotto

:blobbox:

 

stamina, chin, speed, ring smarts could also go to floyd. so basically, all you got is floyd + others' power and heart (who said floyd doesnt have heart?)

 

::

 

He's not "deficient" in those areas but this about the best in each one.

 

Floyd has excellent stamina, but I'll put guys ahead like Manny Pacquiao and Juan Diaz because they show it more with their styles. Maybe Mayweather can throw that many shots and still be very fresh, maybe he'll fatigue a bit, but I'll just put guys that I've seen throw a ridiculous amount of shots, use some movement, and still go strong late in the fight.

Same with chin...Floyd seems to have a good chin, but it's not like he gets hit flush on the chin very often. We've seen guys like Oliver McCall, Lamon Brewster, and James Toney (although he rolls well with the shots) take a lot of heavy leather extremely well.

Defense and ring smarts can be either Floyd or B-Hop....interchangable to me.

 

how about the weakest fighter ever?

chin - augie sanchez
heart - freitas or golata
stamina - judah
speed - valuev
power - calderon
ring generalship - mundine
cuts - martin castillo
footwork - ponce de leon
professionalism - toney (roids) or jl castillo(weight)
trainer - oscar suarez
promoter - murad mohammad

 

What's wrong with choosing Cotto for power? :tease:

 

1. Stamina------------------Sakio Bika
2. Boxing ability-------------Joe Cal
3. Defense------------------Turdy
4. Chin-------------------Wayne Mac
5. Footwork---------------Mozley
6. Speed-----------------Zab
7. Power-------------------Wlad
8. Killer instinct-------------Wlad
9. Ring smarts---------------James Toney
10. Heart--------------------Cotto

 

stamina: Ouma
Boxing Ability: Mayweather
Defense: Mayweather
Chin: Sam Peter
Footwork: Mayweather
Speed: Mayweather
Power: Raffy Marquez
Killer Instinct: Pacquiao
Ring Smarts: Mayweather
Heart: Cotto

 

Since it would be easiest to pick some unknown or a guy like Eric Crumble, I'll just pick current fighters who were at one point, titlists or contenders.

Chin - Bruce Seldon
Heart/Mental Stability - Andrew Golota
Stamina- Shannon Briggs
Speed - Carlos Baldomir
Power - Ivan Calderon
Ring Generalship - David Tua
Professionalism - James Toney
Ring Smarts- Zab Judah

 

This is going to be fun:bears:

 

power cotto? are you serious?

 

1. Stamina - Manny Pacquiao
2. Boxing ability - Floyd Mayweather Jr.
3. Defense - Winky Wright
4. Chin - Bernard Hopkins
5. Footwork - Floyd Mayweather Jr.
6. Speed - Manny Pacquiao
7. Power - Manny Pacquiao
8. Killer instinct - Manny Pacquiao
9. Ring smarts - Floyd Mayweather Jr.
10. Heart - Manny Pacquiao

 

weakest fighter continued...

activity rate/punch output - hopkins
stink level - spinks
consistency - judah
excuses - judah
brittle hands - malignaggi
ring attire - chop chop corley
personality - tarver
ego - tarver
physique - marcos primera or toney
hype level - jdon codrington
luck w/ judges - jermain taylor

 

Whats wrong with this?:tease: Cotto has shown to have power that breaks his opponents down.

 

I think cotto has more heart than he does power.

He has power, yes, but its his perseverance that allows his power to shine thru.

He persevered against Torres, as he did with Judah. His lip was punched thru and he shook it off and kept coming.

Whoever takes Cottos "0" will really and truly have to nail him down.

 

well he knocked his dick off, then he kept coming

 

1. Stamina - Pacquiao
2. Boxing ability - JMM
3. Defense - Toney
4. Chin - McCullough
5. Footwork - PBF
6. Speed - Judah
7. Power - Tua
8. Killer instinct - Pacquiao
9. Ring smarts - Hopkins
10. Heart - Morales

What about in-fighting? - Castillo

 

Why do people assume that Pac has mad Stamina???

Surely Marquez gets the stamina nod over Pac??:dunno:

Fuck it....Pac gassed more from the 1st round in their fight than JMM....and JMM was the one getting floored.

Try not to confuse "all action" with "stamina".

Ricky Hatton has displayed stamina....but against Collazo and Urango, that was patently absent.

 

Hatton's stamina is a myth. The only reason he doesn't collapse is because he holds for 2 1/2 minutes of every round. So in essence, he's constantly taking a break. Lampley will have you believe that Hatton is in perpetual motion and that he's a machine, because, well, Lampley doesn't watch fights, he just calls them.

Pacquiao's stamina is amazing when you consider the work-rate that he maintains consistently throughout a fight, and that he's almost always on the offensive. In other words, he expends more energy than his opponents on a consistent basis and still has more left in the tank. That's why when he fights it seems like he's fighting at a completely different pace. He is. His opponents can't keep up with him. If I had to pick one thing about Pacquiao that makes him special it is the pace he's able to maintain throughout a fight. It allows him to dismantle his opponents and not let them breath.

 

Dude there have been some dumb things said lately, but JMM has better boxing ability than Floyd mayweather...

cmon now

 

:: I was gonna say.

 

news for YOU dude. what PBF does is not boxing. not in a traditional sense. do you even know what boxing is?

 

Is muhammad ali a great boxer?...how about Pernell Whitaker or Larry holmes?

 

categories that should be added:

in-fighting - Castillo

counter-punching - JMM

pot-shotter - PBF

 

yes. all three of them are. and PBF doesn't fight like any of them.