Here they are in order from my perspective. Reason I rate Carwin win so low is because Carwin in reality beat himself. 1. MIR 2. Couture 3. Herring 4. Carwin 5. Asian guy
None anything super special. Couture was a small old man, Herring shot, Carwin is overhyped with no gas tank. So I'd say Mir.
Carwin win is only good on paper. W over Carwin sounds good but if you actually saw the fight it was not a good win at all.
Of course, whether or not I saw the fight is dependent on me having the same opinion as you. Perfect sequitur argument.