He's 2-3 in my book now over the last few days. Those three being excruciatingly painful losses in fights which start off entertaining for all of a few minutes and then turn into literal butcherings.
Arguello beats him every time. He's beaten better versions of Gatti such as Chacon, Boza Edwards, Ray Mancini.
If gatti is lucky, he might score a falsh kd a la gannigan, but besides that slim possibility, its a massacre