I suppose I'd agree with X, and take Ben. Gatti's best performance around that weight was Dorin, IMO. He did box well, but ultimately before landing that shot, was on his way to going back to brawling. That suits Tackie IMO.
i think gatti has enough boxing ability and durability to win a decision here. tackie was easy to outbox so you know gatti is winning the rounds. the only question is, does tackie "robert garcia" him. i don't think so.