Trinidad sucked at 160. Who'd he beat? Very old/shot versions of Joppy, Chefri and Mayorga? And you think he's any good?
Taylor had Pavlik out in round 2. That fight was close to being over but Taylor could not end it. I say Tito can! Tito has a much better selection of punches and hits harder than Taylor. Tito TKO Pavlik in 6!
Toto cant fight going back, only coming forward. I think Pavlik would force him back from the opening bell with his size, and thudding jab. Tito would probably have him in trouble at some point, but I dont see him really being able to finish him either. Tito wasnt much of a finisher at 160. If he was, Joppy wouldnt have lasted past round 2. Pavlik would bomb him out with right hands, Tito wouldnt be able to avoid Kelly's cross to save his life.
I actually give Tito a chance here. Pavlik comes to you and tries to outpunch you with no defense. Tito was a tough hombre and he never lost a fight where a guy was going blow for blow with him with no defense. I'm not saying for sure Tito beats Pavlik because it wasn't Tito's natural division, but P4P I'd easily pick Tito and even at 160 I pick Tito though a bit more hesitantly.