Watched Fight Club once. Made zero impression on me. In fact I thought Fincher's The Game was probably better...
Fight Club has grown on me. I think it's a really good movie, actually. The twist is way overrated though, and somewhat predictable. But it's still a quality movie to watch. Se7en is a cinematic classic and imo one of the 10 best films of the 90s, so this is a no brainer for me. And yes Mostarda, The Game is an excellent movie, and has a good case over Fight Club.
If you had asked me after 1st viewings I would have said "Seven" easily. However, I've found "Fight Club" much more rewatchable. I like the characters in it. At first the twist at the end was a big disappointment to me, but instead of ruining the rest of the movie for later viewings, it caused me to see different things Fincher was going for and just enjoy it for what it was. "Fight Club" is kind of fun, "Seven" is just a joyless movie with not much going for it, once the "mystery" is solved.
Love 7...watch it a bunch of times....dark and depressing.....but I love it. Fight Club is okay...Helena could get her dirty cunt fuck all day every day....back int he day...not now...eww.