It would look exactly the same as their actual fight went down. Prime-for-prime George blows Cooney away in 2 just as he did in 89. Cooney NEVER had the chin to handle George's heat.
More than Probably Any "Big" Heavyweight of That Era, Gerry Cooney NEEDED His Size Advantage... George Foreman Had a GREAT Chin and was a LOT More Physically Imposing In his Prime...He'd WRECK Cooney w/Little to No Fuss... REED