HAtton Vs Judah, Prime for Prime.

Probably this means the Hatton that fought Zoo and the Judah that..............fought Zoo. ::

I think Ricky tastes canvas but that Judah sort of just caves in mentally and lets Hatton win more rounds than he loses.

 

Yup, basically agree.

Zab certainly had the talent to beat Hatton, but not the intangibles.

He badly rocks Hatton at some point, but lets him off the hook and blows it.

 

What weight are we talking though, Irish?

Hatton wins at 140.

At 147, I pick Zab.

 

Hatton at 140 definitely... Judah looks great for 10 minutes and fades, Hatton surges... Unanimous decision

 

140 and 147 if you want.

I think Judah just found ways to lose, sort of a refined Golota.

 

Hatton at both weights.

 

They were both basically the same fighters at both weights. Zab was a small 147 lber who moved back down to 140.

 

Judah wins because Hatton was wank

 

Attraction N Action.

 

I'm with Hatton at 140, Judah at 147.

I'd pick the Judah that KO'd Spinks over the Hatton that beat Collazo, I think. Otherwise, I'd pretty much always go with Hatton.

 

If it's the mega-motivated Hatton who fought Mayweather at 147, I think I'd take him over any version of Judah. So I guess I can see a certain scenario where Judah wins, but Hatton most of the time. I'm a big believer that a fighters edge changes from fight to fight.

 

I just want to reiterate that my pick of Hatton in no way changes the fact that he was one of the most horrible fighters to watch in history and he should have been a cagefighter

 

This is a tough one,,

I really wanna say Zab, if you look at Zab that fought floyd and Hatton
In that fight Zab was so sharp, FAST hard body shots

I think in those versions I'd pick Zab