Both at thier bests I think it'd be a high class chessmatch. Not one casual fans would enjoy, but one a purist would love. I pick Eddie though, as he wouldnt be coming at JT, and from range I see Eddie more effective. It'd be a pretty close fight though. This is assuming of course that hypothetically the Toney of Barkley fight form were to show up at 175. Eddie would beat the crap outta the sluggish Toney that lost to midget Griffin.
