Montiel vs Castillo- who wins?

who wins?
________
Lovely Wendie99

 

Toss up, extremely hard to bet on IMO. Who did you take?

 

maybe i'm wrong, but i see this is a clear favorite for castillo.

 

havent bet yet...im going with the "ask he audience" lifeline ...hurry up! i gotta get down to the strip soon!
________
Paxil help

 

I didn't end up betting. Castillo came in to about +110 and thats a little too tight for my liking.

 

awesome fight! I've been wanting to see this fight for years.

I've always liked Montiel better. But I think he has been too inactive. Against Castillo you can't be rusty.

It's a toss up really, but guaranteed to be an awesome fight.

 

Both guys are on the decline IMO. The best bet is that it will go 12. I can't see a KO unless Castillo is stopped on cuts.

 

it was a better fight 3 years ago or so, not as much now.

 

not the fans

we got this, mijares, viloria all on the same card.

I know Santa Anita has been having some kind of problems with the track but fuck can't this be kept to a minimum

 

Get a new line, please.

 

I thought the Santa Anita bit was fresh:dunno:

Ike's making his trek down, its gonna be a midget-bashing extravaganza

 

I'm sure you'll be very happy.

 

......

The title of this thread doesn't ask for fake boxing fans.

 

nothing fake, its a legitimate criticism to suppose that guys that size couldn't beat up the average 200lb man in an actual fight.

I don't hate on it as much as others, but sometimes its tough watching a fight knowing there won't be a KO no matter what

 

nonsense. Montiel would beat the hell out of me, and I am nothing if not average.

 

until you've stood next to someone that size, u can't even imagine how small they are.

Brain Viloria came up to the bottom of my shoulder, and has the sense of size of an 11 year old girl...I'm a skinny pussy who weighs 150, he'd probably take me in a streetfight, but not anyone I know of reasonable stature

 

It's not legitimate at all. Isn't the sport called boxing? I would take any of the 4 smaller guys to kick your ass in the boxing ring. It's a stupid argument. There is weight classes in most combat sports for a reason.

BTW-There are some good punchers in those classes. That's a stupid generalization.

 

There's no way Rod Coleman could outrun DeAngelo Hall. For shame!

 

no it isnt.

yes any professional of any size would crucify me in boxing, but part of the suspense is the potential for a fight-changing punch. At those weights, more often than not, what you end up with is action filled but drama-less rounds.

I never used to rip small weight classes until I went live and stood next to people that size. Its just embarassing, on TV you can't really tell but they are abnormally small humans. The best 106lb boxer ever could never beat up Jim Lampley in an actual fight, and that kinda takes away the allure for me and others

 

An actual fight? I thought this is a sport of boxing? I am confusing the 2 or something? Oh and yeah it's a stupid generalization saying none of the guys in those classes can punch. There are decent punchers in those classes. Funny though, a lot of people would rather watch 2 guys gas out after 5 rounds and hold the shit out of each other.

 

Ill go with Castillo by UD.

 

show me where I said "none of the guys in those classes can punch"

 

.....

My post......
BTW-There are some good punchers in those classes. That's a stupid generalization.

You posting underneath my post.....
no it isnt.

 

which refers back to my original generalization, which was..."its tough watching a fight knowing there won't be a KO no matter what"

Yes this can be said about other divisions, but how many "one-punch" KO's are there amongst top level guys below 122?

 

....

What was KO of the year last year again? It's actually pretty funny. There aren't a lot of 1 punch KO guys in ANY divisions to be honest. I don't see any Julian Jackson's around.

 

From about 13 months ago...top 10 guys in each weight class per boxrec...
Weight/ KO % of top 10 guys
105 52
108 59
112 61
115 48
118 62
122 71
126 60
130 66
135 62
140 67
147 71
154 64
160 65
168 66
175 65
200 71
Hvy 78

Keep in mind that these %'s will include performances where the junior bantam might have weighed 115 3/4 lbs and therefore, was not technically a junior bantam. (sorry)

 

how can anyone watch this shit?

 

Did Free Ike hijack your account.

 

Nice work by Montiel:bears:

 

i was about to bet this, but Castillo was fucked after this posting BIG TIME!!! :laughing: