ODLH Scorecards

Im interested, especially after last night, to see how people actually scored all of Oscars close fights. Personally Ive always thought he was good for the sport and as such people watching tend to dwell more on what Oscar does rather than his opponent. A such I have listed how I scored each one of what is classed as a close deciosn at the time and then again minus commentary. Wondered how everyone elses compared.

ODLH 113 PBF 115 (113-116 MINUS COMMENTARY)

At time of stoppage ODLH 74 BHOP 78 (74-78 MINUS COMMENTARY)

ODLH 112 Sturm 116 (114-114 MINUS COMMENTRAY)

ODLH 114 SSM 115 (2ND FIGHT) (114-115 MINUS COMMENTARY)

At time of stoppage ODLH 95 Vargas 95 (96-94 MINUS COMMENTARY)

ODLH 113 SSM 115 (1ST FIGHT) (113-116 MINUS COMMENTARY)

ODLH 116 TITO 112 (115-114 MINUS COMMENTARY)

ODLH 114 QUARTEY 114 (115-113 MINUS COMMENTARY)

OLDH 114 Sweet Pea 114 (114-114 MINUS COMMENTARY)

 

you had sturm dlh a drew?

sturm beat his ass

 

I don't pay attention to the commentary anymore.

 

Best I can remember:

Oscar vs. Mayweather 110-118
Oscar vs. Sturm 112-116
Oscar vs. Hopkins 74-79
Oscar vs. Shane II 115-113
Oscar vs. Vargas 95-95
Oscar vs. Shane I 113-116
Oscar vs. Tito 116-113
Oscar vs. Quartey 113-113
Oscar vs. Pernell 114-112

 

Wasn't it KO magazine that ran an article about De la Hoya-Quartey looking more like a decision for Oscar in the second viewing?

 

Nigel Collins, Ring Magazine. Scored it for Quartey from ringside, DLH on VHS.

 

Whitaker: Even 113-113
Quartey: Quartey 114-113
Trinidad: De La Hoya 115-114
Mosley II: De La Hoya 116-113
Sturm: Sturm, I can't remember if I had it 115-113 or 116-112
Mayweather: Mayweather 116-112
Hopkins: Hopkins 77-75 at the time of the stoppge
Vargas: De La Hoya 96-94 at the time of the stoppage