Rank these welterweights

In terms of peak ability

Joshua Clottey
Marlon Starling
Ike Quartey
Oba Carr
Derel Coley
Ricardo Mayorga
Colin Jones
Wilfredo Rivera
Buddy McGirt
Paul Williams

Just curious. Bang 'em out, rapid fire, best to worst. There may be a point to this, may not be.

 

I really dont feel like ranking them all, but so I'll just the top 3.

1. Starling
2. Ike
3. Tall Paul

Coley is dead last in terms of ability.

And Clottey is dead last in terms of heart.

 

Starling is clearly the best of all of those fighters

 

Agreed with Xplosive's top 3.

That's a really hard list to rank. If i made one right now, i'd probably disagree with it tomorrow.

 

List!

 

as long as Starling is number one and Quartey is at 2 or 3, its a good list.... anything else is just stupid