I would have said Bradley before the Catterrall fight. Timmy is far too dynamic and multidimensional for Josh. Clear UD win for Braddles.
Fun fight. Bradley was far more crafty and versatile than Taylor and I think he would have beaten him by clear cut decision.
To be very honest, I don't see Josh as even a lock over the 2011 Devon Alexander. Bradley was damn near a underdog going into that fight. Devon was extremely highly regarded at the time, and with the traits he had, I could EASILY envision Alexander outboxing Taylor. I just don't think Josh is all that good. If he were around in 2000, he'd be on Sharma Mitchell level. I see him closer to Mitchell's level than the likes of a Tszyu, Cotto, Hatton, Bradley, ect.