Cotto took 11 rounds to do so. Forrest wasn't a HUGE puncher and neither was he particularly agressive. Decision is the safer bet.
he is 6 feet tall with a jab, you cant make the comparison to Cotto, anymore than you would compare Cotto to Spinks Judah is NEVER getting away from him or his jab, he's NEVER getting inside since when is big time power required to hurt or stop Zab Judah? Forrest certainly hit as hard as Cotto and harder than a bunch of other guys who have hurt Judah stylewise, Judah cant do anything here except eat jabs, when he tries to throw real power shots, he's eating right hands and he's getting knocked the hell out
Who has stopped Judah besides Tszyu and Cotto? The Tzsyu fight isn't evidence in itself of a bad chin. Zab foolishly walked into a flush right hand with his hands down (he was trying to be slick). That happens in boxing. Does Lennox have a bad chin just because of the 1st Rahman fight?
Getting hurt badly by guys like CARLOS BALDOMIR and Lucas Matthysse, running for his fucking life against basically anyone that landed a few flush shots against him... THAT is the evidence he has a shit chin and a tiny heart to go along with it again, he's a Mayweather victim so you have to make him seem formidable when the guy is in fact a front-running failure
I pick Forrest by decision as well... but c'mon Sly. People can dress it up and say Judah had poor balance, took foolish chances, etc. but whose to say that none of that would've happened against Forrest. I mean, Cory Spinks knocked him down for chrissakes.