I've only seen one Davey Moore fight besides the Duran & Benitez fights (Charlie Weir) & he certainly looked a far, far, far better fighter than David Reid. Their respective opposition before taking their beatings favours Moore & Moore was far more dominant over them. I think he's flat out better. That said, my biases being what they are & the implications of my pick being what they are.... people can take my opinion FWIW. Moore wide UD.
Moore by late KO or one-sided decision (due to several knockdowns) much stronger man, harder puncher Reid was shite