Ive got Qawi by decision. Simply by virtue of being the bigger man. Tiger was great though, and would make it highly competitive. Dick Tiger is the type of fighter that coulda REALLY benefitted if there was a 168 in his day. He was too big for 160, but too small for 175.
no argument here Tiger beat Jose Torres by fighting decidedy unlike himself... moving, jabbing, punching to the body and getting out... it worked partly because Torres was not expecting it (the second match was far closer) and because Torres simply was not as good as Qawi, nor was his style as suitable for dealing with Tiger as Qawi's would be