Wow. A true pick em. If they fought 10 times, they might just split 5. Both were tough SOB's and this would certainly be a war. With a gun to my head, I pick Brown. Simon was quicker, and a bit more technically skilled.
Agreed on it being a pick-em. Brown would probably land some of the crisper shots, but Palomino would make up for it with activity. Close decision either way.