Kind of inspired by Flo's latest thread (nice idea Flo): We always discuss our fantasy MMs, but we haven't really discussed what would be our fantasy P4P matchups - assuming both guys were the same natural weight and maintained their prime abilities. Some of mine: 168 Jones vs 147 Leonard 147 Robinson vs 135 Duran Tyson vs Pryor 118 Jofre vs 130 Arguello Sanchez vs Monzon 122 Gomez vs 135 Ortiz Hagler vs 135 Chavez Yalls?
I wonder how a Holmes vs McCallum P4P matchup would play out. I suspect Larry wins. I think Holmes had more intangibles than McCallum and an extra gear that McCallum lacked. But it's a great matchup.
Leonard vs Charles Moore vs Duran Fenech vs Frazier Chang vs Chavez Napoles vs Jones Olivares vs Sanchez Canto vs Saldivar Pryor vs Qawi Spinks vs Jofre Harada vs Hagler
Fenech vs Frazier is a nice one. I'd favor Joe to stop Fenech in the end, but it sure would be savage.
Joe Louis vs Pernell Whitaker Mike Tyson vs Thomas Hearns Archie Moore vs Julio Cesar Chavez Willie Pep vs Jung Koo Chang Fritzie Zivic vs Sandy Saddler Roy Jones Jr vs Roberto Duran
Ive never thought about this before but Sanchez vs Hagler immediately popped into my head so first thought best thought. Fascinating style blend between two guys made of quartz
Jones jr vs Leonard Trinidad vs Chavez Tyson vs Hagler Benitez vs Whitaker Sanchez vs Hearns De La Hoya vs Canelo Floyd vs Monzon
You can't find a worse P4P style matchup for Tyson than Hagler. Love Mike, but P4P Marvin would take Mike apart.
Roberto Duran 135 vs Mike Tyson Pernell Whitaker 135 vs Muhammad Ali Julio Cesar Chavez 135 vs Joe Frazier Wilfredo Gomez 122 vs Felix Trinidad Marvin Hagler 160 vs Evander Holyfield Orlando Canizales 118 vs José Napoles Eusebio Pedroza 126 vs Sugar Ray Leonard Johnny Tapia 115 vs Jeff Fenech Mark Johnson 112 vs Roy Jones Jr
Tyson vs McClellan is a P4P matchup I've always thought of. I think Mike would destroy Gerald inside of 6-7, but it'd be violent while it lasts.
Imagine a bigger version of Sandy Saddler or Eusebio Pedroza against Bernard Hopkins or Andre Ward. Dirty fighting galore.
Pryor vs Saad Camacho vs Hamed - They'd Bring a Heightened, Matching Level of Shock Value and Unpredictability to the Occasion...Fuck the Thigh Baring Trunks, REED Could See Camacho Trying to Go Completely TrunkLESS or Whipping Out Some SEE THRU Trunks, @ Least...Everything About This SCREAMS "Over the Top", They'd Bring Unparalleled Levels of COLLECITVE Showmanship Out of Each Other, and REED Suspects the Fight Would Be More ENTERTAINING Than Some Would Imagine... REED
Pryor vs Saad would be a violent one for sure. In the end, violent for Saad. Hawk would tear Saad apart P4P.
