I hadn't noticed that. Good spot.
You don't like the P4P discussion, never have and so you try to fuck up P4P threads at every opportunity to suit your agenda. Here's the deal:...
Nonsense. Silly way to look at it. P4P is basically saying "how good is he for his size". Pacquaio is a small guy, a former Flyweight. Now...
Yeah yeah....I've been hearing this for years. Floyd ducked a prime Cotto, blah blah When Floyd was at 140lbs, Cotto wasn't ready for him. When...
In all honesty, Cotto SHOULDN'T win this fight. If he wins it's an enormous upset, IMO. Floyd could beat him boxing, on the inside, mid...
<iframe src="http://www.youtube.com/embed/0_GTNv0J9e8" allowfullscreen="" frameborder="0" height="315" width="560"></iframe>
Anyway... If we take speed outta the equation and are just looking at textbook skill...there are only two men in history to consider for the...
There weren't many, I grant you that but there were a handful of fighters that were comparable to Jones in terms of speed. Zab Judah for example....
:mj:
:bears: Perhaps you've seen the light and recognize the greatness.
:giggle: You're just trying to jinx him! In the past you've invariably picked against him.
:lol: Suddenly Watson was this killa! Last I checked the only meaningful win of Watson's career was against Nigel Benn, and that was more...
I mean was Darth Maul less skillful than Qui Gon Jinn just because he used the unconventional double Lightsaber? The hole in Qui Gon's chest...
All of you guys are fucking crazy.:atu: Hit and not get hit is a SKILL, motherfuckers! I don't give a shit if you do it conventionally or...
You are as fickle as a 10 dollar ho! The Taylor that was destroyed by Abraham and Froch was a diminished fighter (Physically and mentally) and...
Who gives a shit? I saw a guy that could do all sorts of amazing tricks with his bicyle...all manner of flips and hops and mad shit. He...
I have no problem ranking heavyweights. For example in 1988, Mike Tyson was undoubtedly P4P#1 (honorable mention to JCC) Ali in the 60s was...
Dawson by decision in a very dull cagey fight. Hopkins is too old to continue to compete at this level.
ok...forget Martinez...Floyd/Manny and then the rest. I mean let's all be reasonable men.
You've always had a strange notion of what P4P best means. Wlad, as a heavyweight, is far more vulnerable than Floyd is as a Welterweight. If...
You're insane! :notallthere: Floyd/Manny/Martinez are an impenetrable top 3 until one of them is beaten.
Taylor would have beaten Watson.
word. Roy was skillful....fuck Hut and Cdogg...with all due respect to my boyz! :lol:
Ali couldn't beat Norton (without controversy), so fucking what? He beat Foreman and Liston. Who cares if a 40 year old Hopkins couldn't beat...
If we are just talking teachable skill....this topic is fucked up. There are lots of textbook fighters (Michael Watson for example) that Roy...
That's what I mean....you are complicating the issue. Complicating issue = fucking up topic
Irrelevant. 20 successful defenses of the title and he fought everyone that there was to fight including other titlists as well as Trinidad and...
We have to therefore choose a definition that suits us, define it and then formulate a list. Arguing over the meaning of the word "skill" is...
I'm going to assume you mean talent (who beats who talent...not just fucking "athleticism") 1. Jones 2. Ali 3. mayweather 4. Leonard 5....
Anyway this is the definitive top 5 all time middleweight list: :kidcool: 1. Hopkins 2. Monzon 3. Hagler 4. Robinson 5. Greb
Separate names with a comma.
