This fight sucks. Shane is scared shitless to throw anything. Pathetic. And Manny isn't even pressing.
Man, stop with all the glove touching. They touched gloves after the knockdown. WTF?
Shane looks like he's standing in quicksand. Old
Shane via TKO 4!!!
That's what I call a silver lining. Just saying.
One for the DVR of the die hards. If you've followed Bellator this season, then you've seen the organization heavily promote their top...
His Strikeforce contract allows him to participate in pro boxing. It will be interesting to see what happens.
If he gets big money for Lacy, it's freak show money and nothing else. I maybe dumb enough to think Nick's work rate and chin could carry him to...
Manny looks far bigger. This should be an easy fight.
Oh boy.. I guess this means we won't get GSP-Diaz anytime soon. I think Zuffa is making a huge mistake not letting Nick fight GSP sooner rather...
You realize you're contradicting yourself and talking in circles, right? You just touched on the exact reasons I mentioned for having Edgar ahead...
The belt? WTF How does that carry any weight in a P4P discussion?
Well, wait a second. You've been railing for hours now about how P4P is about who could beat who. Yet I don't see Maynard anywhere on your top 10...
By the way, it now deserves a thread of it's own.... LOL
So, who wins the rematch Edgar or Maynard?
Great mentions already. I will add a few of my favorites: Jason Isaacs-----The Patriot Jack Nicholson-----A Few Good Men Tom Berenger------Platoon
In order for Anthony's scenario to work, Melendez would have to catch Edgar with a shot like Maynard did. Keep in mind that other solid strikers...
So you're picking Edgar in the rematch with Maynard?
Well, I figured you would have to run there sooner or later. Again, that is a contest. Often you have to make picks to make up ground that go...
Well, I am a huge fan of the BJJ taught in that camp. Those guys are among the best. But the truth is, Melendez has never demonstrated an ability...
I would absolutely pick Edgar over Melendez. Without hesitation. The only guy to beat Edgar is Maynard, who is the best wrestler in the division...
Based on what? Speculation? Melendez has beaten anyone of that caliber. Ever.
BJ start talking retirement went he lost 2 straight to Edgar. Coming of the huge win against Sanchez, BJ was even remotely thinking retirement. In...
Melendez isn't a lock to beat any of the top LW's in the world Seriously, Edgar, Maynard, Alvarez, Pettis, Henderson, Miller, etc are all better...
Yeah and Edgar has beaten a better list of "WHO" by a mile. LOL at BJ in his prime. BJ just fought to a draw with one of the best Welterweights...
Dude, that is revisionist. Griffin, Sherk, Franca and even Fisher were regarded guys when Edgar fought them. To say otherwise NOW is just...
No, because he beat: Jim Miller Tyson Griffin Mark Boecek Spencer Fisher Hermes Franca Sean Sherk AND BJ Penn twice. There is absolutely NO...
Wow, Gilbert Melendez at 3.... I'll admit, Gilbert is a guy that I just couldn't rank properly. The dude walked through Aoki. He demolished...
No, you're right. In fact, I think TJ is the reason the WBC outlawed the use of coolness of temper and disposition.
My list: 1) GSP 2) Anderson Silva 3) Jon Jones 4) Jose Aldo 5) Eddie Alvarez 6) Nick Diaz 7) Frankie Edgar 8) Gilbert Melendez 9) Cain Velasquez...
Separate names with a comma.
