Agreed. I don't see the comparison. Mosley beat his Tyson (ODLH). Twice. Ruddock lost to his. Twice. Like I said if you could jump in a time...
Well he did go to Balco to get supplements because he was weight lifting but I'm sure the fact that you saw him get bigger proves your theory; I...
I personally have always thought that what Nady did gets so overrated. He prevented Ruiz from clinching right? Well you don't score points from a...
When you first made your long post you almost had me worried, but I thought, let me rewatch the Collazo fight and see if he was correct first. So...
Just got through rewatching this fight and I must have missed the parts where Collazo was making Shane look silly and clowning him. Yeah, Collazo...
Well try to read the whole thread LOK. That's what people write it for.
This is going to be a PPV right? Man you guys better follow my lead. This will be one to skip for the ages. I'm not even sure I want to see it at...
Wow, Cuevas most really suck. Let me guess, were basing Mayorga off of his 1 awesome win over Forrest rather than his mediocre career as a whole...
So while Shane was putting in some of his most dominate work and would have been pretty much favored over everyone in the division Larry Merchant...
You know I consistently hear this as the excuse that so called Shane fans claim as the reason they argue against him. Here's why I raise the...
Gotta agree, because I was certain Nady would disqualify Tarver for hitting on the break, throwing a punch with his eyes closed or any morbid...
I wasn't trying to say Wright would win or even last the distance. I was merely disagreeing with the argument you were using.
Although I've never seen Cuevas fight he should likely wipe the floor with Mayorga just off of his rep alone. Mayorga was nothing more than a...
Uhhh. Camacho too damn quick. Wins a wide UD. I'm talking borderline every rd here.
Exactly. Holy by KO.
No shit. If anything that analogy would have worked better when Cotto fought Judah.
Winky against Vargas/Taylor - Throw away your patented defense that got you there, and instead brawl.
He also serves a bigger purpose. By pricing Joel out of fights, he reduces pains from infecting my eyes.
Disagree. He didn't employ his defense in either the Vargas fight or the Taylor fight. He fought aggressively against both in order to make a more...
Like I've often explained to brother Ike. Another indicator of greatness is ones longevity as champion and how impressively they've defeated their...
True, but if Shane doesn't have enough left to beat Cotto, there really isn't much point in him fighting Floyd, and likewise if Cotto were to...
This is becoming one of the biggest pieces of cliche'ic bullshit on this site. First of all TARVER didn't even fight the 3rd fight with any fire,...
Even a number of Roy's fans in Pensacola started having "Roycotts" of his fights because of the lack of competition he was routeinly facing.
:bears: Cool story Reed. I sympathize with you and have a newfound respect for you as a Roy fan. I had similar feelings when Mosley suffered his...
Uh, check the post by Explosive. Fruitass=Freitas.
Completely agree FoM. The 1st time I saw that fight I too thought it was close. Go back and rewatch it and you'll see that Shane seemed to be...
What you've got there Joony my friend is the beginnings of a top 5 list. Great job. :clap:
Whether Ring rated Sosa's chin best in the universe doesn't change my opinion of Roy's power. What does though is me reassessing him. After...
Tua hasn't been relevant for years. He hasn't been effective for even longer and he's making a comeback at an age where he should be retired. Can...
Gotta agree. This guy makes Spinks look like a fucking matador.
Separate names with a comma.
