We've done this thread before, but not in a while. List some fights where you feel the outcome would change if the loser was in their prime. The...
Who wins? I expect to everyone to say Calzaghe, but its funny how opinions change. I remember the Calz vs Michalczewski question getting posed...
Who wins?
Self-explanatory. Four notables: 1. Liston. Sonny was 6'0, with an 84 inch reach - the exact same reach as Lennox Lewis. Crazy. 2. Hearns:...
Who wins the following matchups? Louis-Holmes Louis-Liston Louis-Frazier Frazier-Holmes Frazier-Liston Liston-Holmes
Let's say they meet circa 1990, when Tapia was in his real physical prime.
Just rewatched Louis-Braddock. Almost 100 years later, and Joe Louis remains the most flawless puncher the sport has ever had. The Brown Bomber's...
Eubank have a chance?
In history, there's been three performances by teenagers taking the title that really stand-out, and here's all three. The first is famous and...
Pre-prison Tyson vs Wilder is obviously a mismatch. Even 96 Tyson vs Wilder is a mismatch imo. So, how does Wilder fare against 2000 Tyson? The...
Let's say at 122. Who wins?
Given his age, his complete lack of skill to fall back on, and the fact that he's taken back-to-back brutal beatings, is Wilder finished as a top...
Let's give this one a rewatch for those who have seen it, or a first watch for anyone who hasn't. Easily one of the most beautiful, flawless...
Mid 80s Curry vs mid 90s Ike. My feelings on this matchup have shifted. I used to say Curry would have picked Ike apart, but now I dont know. I...
Who wins? The Nelson that stopped Gomez versus the Ramos that stopped Davey Moore. Well, sadly more than just stopped him.... I think Nelson...
Bradley have a chance? Or is the talent gap too big?
At say, 185. Who wins?
Not going the distance either way. Who wins? I'm kinda siding with Bruno. He was more durable, at least early on, and I cant see Tommy handling...
Rank these three psychos in terms of the potential they had if they didn't blow it: Ibeabuchi Ayala Jr Valero Ike seemed to be a lot better than...
Let this topic serve as the official thread to carry us through the weekend. Final thoughts and predictions? Anyone give Beyonce a chance? Anyone...
Name some examples of MMs that would be mismatches, but exciting to watch. Some examples: Prime Tyson vs Tua: The 80s Mike would light Tua up...
We all know the usual suspects who have legendary peaks that are always talked about: 40s Robinson, 70s Duran, 87-88 Tyson, 64-67 Ali, 90s Jones,...
Tszyu was a southpaw killer. Could he take out the ultimate southpaw?
Who wins? Honeyghan battered a Curry who wasn't 100%. Espana battered a shopworn Taylor. Both guys were offensively talented, though I think...
Separate names with a comma.
