I don't really hold Baldomir and Gomez against him. Baldomir (fuckin sicko that he is) was way too big for Gatti, and Gomez was his final fight where he was completely used up. The Manfredy and Robinson ass whuppins, however, should have automatically disqualifed him from the HOF. Shit, might as well throw Manfredy in if that's the standard. Manfredy beat better opposition than Gatti.
I think gatti jas beaten better opposition than manfredy, but he clearly doesn't deserve to be in the hof