In your mind. I recall it being a split decision and with good reason, plus Hopkins scored the only KD of the fight. As Hut suggested, how is this evidence that Joe would have beaten any version of Hopkins.
Hopkins had a great start, then done nothing noteworthy after round three when Calzaghe adjusted. He should have had at least a point off too for either the blatant play acting or the numerous headbutts. It was an uncomfortable nights work for sure, but it was a clear Calzaghe win. Fuck Adelaide Byrd.