Who wins? I've got McGirt, and probably by late TKO. McGirt was something in the Franke Warren rematch, really took a solid pressure fighter in Warren apart in style. He would walk Hatton into counters all night, and eventually the accumulation would be too much for Ricky.
147 is an utter mismatch. If McGirt had no trouble with Simon Brown at 147, then he's gonna wipe his ass with Ricky. At 140, I wanted to give Hatton a sporting chance.